Are Resort Reviews Reliable? Why Reviews Miss The Mark

Have you ever fallen down the rabbit hole of resort reviews? Have you wondered if the reviews you are reading are actually reliable?

You start researching, and suddenly, one property starts to stand out. The photos are beautiful. The rooms look spacious. The food? Five-Stars. And the reviews? Glowing. People are raving about their stay and calling it the “best vacation ever.”

But here’s the problem. That amazing resort? It might not actually be the right fit for you.

Let me explain.

So, Are Resort Reviews Reliable?

Online reviews are based on other people’s experiences, and what they love might not be what you love.

One couple might call the resort “peaceful and serene,” but forget to mention that “peaceful” meant no music, no nightlife, and very little energy throughout the day. Another might say the resort was “so fun and lively,” and by that they mean there was a foam party at the pool every afternoon.

For some, that’s paradise. For others… not so much.

So if you’re asking if resort reviews are reliable, you’re asking a question that’s completely subjective to someone else’s opinion, and could be far from accurate to your standards!

Mistakes to Avoid

I once had a couple tell me they found the “perfect resort” online. They loved the photos and were sold on the room category. It had a swim-up entrance and checked all their boxes budget-wise. The reviews were great, and they figured it had to be a safe choice. But when they arrived, they realized the vibe was completely off. It was louder than they expected, more family-focused, and not nearly as relaxing as they’d hoped. They ended up spending most of their days away from the resort, trying to salvage the trip with quiet dinners off-site and early mornings on the beach before the crowd rolled in.

They didn’t do anything wrong. They just didn’t realize that the personality of a resort matters just as much as the room or the star rating.

Going Beyond “Reliable” Reviews

This is something I help my clients navigate all the time. Because yes; two resorts can have the same star rating, the same beach, and even similar room types… but feel totally different once you’re there. One might be tucked into a lush, quiet cove with long, leisurely dinners and hammocks by the water. Another might have fire dancers, live DJs, and a pool scene that goes from day to night. Neither is wrong, but one is definitely better for you.

That’s why I spend time getting to know your travel style before making any recommendations. Are you early risers who want to explore and try new things? Are you dreaming of a spa day, followed by room service and watching the sunset from your balcony? Or maybe you want a little of both; a good mix of fun and downtime. Whatever the case, it’s not just about finding a resort that’s beautiful (though we’ll do that too). It’s about finding one that fits you.

If you’re stuck in decision mode and starting to second-guess what you’ve found online, I’d love to help. It’s what I do best – matching travelers with the place that makes them feel like, “Yes. This is exactly what we needed.”

Let’s make sure your next trip doesn’t just look great on Instagram, but actually feels amazing when you’re living it.

Click here to schedule a call, and let’s find the place that truly fits you.